If you’ve been reading any news at all over the last few months, it’s no secret that California’s having some deep-seated budget issues that defy easy fixes. One central piece of those issues is the drive put more and more people in prison over the last couple decades — an action that doesn’t make any of our communities safer, and whose drain on the state budget, after years of being a burden, has finally tipped to unsustainable.
Another piece underlying the current crisis is the series of initiatives that voters have passed over the last few decades, which have too often been contradictory, and aimed at short-term feel-good politics, rather than long-term planning for the sustainability of the state.
Now one of my foundational beliefs is that we all must be able to meaningfully influence decisions that affect our lives. And in that spirit, California’s initiative process is an amazing idea: certain types of decisions must automatically go before the voters (rather than being approved only by elected representatives) to become law, and voters have legal a process for bringing their own proposals before the entire electorate. In practice, though, the system’s fatal flaw is the way it naively overlooks the sheer scale and size of California. This plays out in two ways:
- Campaigns are conducted using mass media that can reach and influence a majority of the electorate, meaning they merely scratch the surface of issues with soundbites.
- Only people and corporations with deep pockets have the resources to pay for these huge media campaigns.
I thought of this today when reading a
discussion by techies of the Apple iPad, announced yesterday. Many commenters lament the locked-down status of Apple products, especially the iPhone and, apparently, the iPad, which prevents tech-minded people from exploring and tweaking much of what’s under the hood without voiding the warranty. But a couple folks chimed in to point out the flip side: Apple is prioritizing providing users with a working environment where they don’t
have to tinker, where the device takes care of the details so they can listen to music or make calls. And to do that, Apple has taken a few things off the table, including tinkering. It’s not a device for people who like to muck around; instead it prioritizes getting things done with a minimum of fuss.
In this scenario, Apple isn’t just a dictator. The company has to earn and keep the trust of people who (might) buy what it’s selling. And while it’s not obvious on the surface, tech companies do a lot of usability testing while developing products — asking (potential) users about the product and how well it does or doesn’t meet expectations. The thing Apple has that California doesn’t is a mechanism that combines input — what people want — with the power and expertise to get it done without damaging the big picture, and with accountability to voters.
As a wide swath of people around the world screamed after the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision, unlimited money from deep pockets — people or corporations — fundamentally perverts democracy. And that’s a big obstacle to accountability right now in California government, which is overwhelmingly to large donors and corporations, rather than to individuals.
But there are other models and actual examples of how we can work and live together differently. One of the most well known is the one the Zapatistas have created in their communities in southern Mexico. Seeing democracy and power as flowing from the bottom up, rather than the top down, the Zapatistas continue to refine a model in which each person has a way to make their voice actually heard, and in which community members are working together to solve problems, rather than seeing community issues as work for a single elected official or prominent community member to “deal with.”
I believe we can transform the way we live together in California, across the U.S., and around the world in a way that, rather than silencing some voices and lifting others, values and builds the voices of each one of us, and helps us learn to talk and listen and work together more skillfully, and to take care of each other.